Compare

Pick a category and see our top-rated products side by side.

Toys & Fetch: top picks side by side

Top rated
Chuckit! Ultra Ball
Swap Chuckit! Ultra Ball for another product
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush
Swap Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush for another product
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck
Swap Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck for another product

Our rating

Chuckit! Ultra Ball: 4.9/5
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush: 4.8/5
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck : 4.7/5

Price

Chuckit! Ultra Ball: $8.79
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush: $19.99
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck : $18.90

Best for

Chuckit! Ultra Ball: High-energy dogs that live for fetch.
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush: Gentle play and cuddling.
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck : Anxious dogs, puppies, and dogs that love to 'mother' their toys.

Top pro

Chuckit! Ultra Ball: Highly durable rubber
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush: Iconic design
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck : Authentic quacking sound

Main drawback

Chuckit! Ultra Ball: Choking hazard for giant breeds (use XL)
Jumbo Lamb Chop Plush: Not for aggressive chewers
Mellow Dog Calming Plush Duck : Not designed for aggressive chewers

Showing two products on small screens. Use Swap to change which ones you see.

Prices may have changed since we checked. Amazon links are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.